The silence that followed wasn't just a lack of sound. It was a vacuum. It sucked the oxygen right out of the room.
Marcus scrambled to his feet, nearly knocking over his glass of bourbon. Sloane stayed on the ottoman, her hand still frozen in mid-air where Marcus had been holding it. Her eyes went from me to Sarah, then back to me, searching for a script that didn't exist.
"Sarah?" Marcus stammered. His voice was two octaves higher than it had been a minute ago. "What are you... why are you here?"
Sarah stepped around the counter. She didn't look like a victim. She looked like a judge. "I'm here for the 'networking,' Marcus. Isn't that what you told me? That you were building 'meaningful connections' tonight?"
She looked at Sloane. "And you must be the 'meaningful connection.' I have to say, the dress is a bit much for a business meeting, don't you think?"
Sloane finally found her voice, but it was sharp and defensive. "Ethan, what the hell is this? You invited her here? To our home?"
"I thought we were having a game night, Sloane," I said, my voice as calm as a bank statement. "I just wanted to make sure everyone who was part of the 'joke' was here to enjoy it."
Maya tried to jump in, her face flushed with a mix of fear and indignation. "Ethan, this is totally uncalled for. You’re blowing this way out of proportion. It was just a bit of fun!"
"A 'bit of fun'?" Sarah turned on Maya. "Is that what you call encouraging a married man with a pregnant wife to cheat for your entertainment?"
The word pregnant hit the room like a physical blow.
Marcus looked like he wanted the floor to swallow him whole. Chloe's hand flew to her mouth, her phone—still recording—dropping onto the sofa.
"Pregnant?" Sloane whispered. She looked at Marcus, her expression shifting from defiance to something ugly. "You didn't say she was pregnant."
"Oh, so that's where your moral line is, Sloane?" I asked. "Married is fine, but pregnant is where you draw the limit? That’s good to know for the future. Or lack thereof."
"Ethan, stop it!" Sloane snapped, standing up. "You’re acting insane. You’ve been spying on us? You’ve been talking to this woman behind my back?"
"I wasn't spying, Sloane. I was investigating," I said. "When a client tells me their 'assets' are safe while they’re actively burning down the warehouse, I don't just take their word for it. I check the logs. And your logs... they’re pretty damning."
I picked up my phone and tapped a button. The large TV in the living room—the one we usually used for movies—flickered to life. I had mirrored my screen.
The "Friday Project" chat appeared in giant, high-definition letters.
The room went deathly quiet as the messages scrolled by. “Marcus thinks I’m the one that got away.” “Ethan’s so oblivious.” “I want to see Ethan’s face when Marcus tries to take her to the balcony.”
Maya and Chloe looked like they wanted to vanish. Chloe reached for her phone, but I was faster.
"Don't worry, Chloe," I said. "I’ve already made a backup of the video you were recording. It’s a great piece of evidence. It shows intent, coordination, and a complete lack of remorse."
"You can't do this!" Chloe shrieked. "That’s private!"
"In my house? Using my WiFi? To document my humiliation?" I shook my head. "I think a judge would disagree. But more importantly, I think your employers might have some questions about 'brand integrity' if this ever went public."
That shut her up instantly. Chloe worked in PR. Maya worked in corporate HR. They both knew exactly how "viral" this could become.
Sarah walked over to Marcus. She didn't yell. She didn't cry. She just held out her hand. "The keys, Marcus. Now."
"Sarah, please, let’s talk privately—"
"There is no 'privately' anymore," she said. "You chose a public stage. You get a public ending. The keys. And don't bother coming to the house. I’ve already called your brother. Your things will be on his porch by midnight."
Marcus looked at Sloane, a desperate, pathetic look. Sloane didn't even look at him. She was looking at me, her face contorted with a mixture of rage and realization.
Marcus handed over the keys and slunk out of the house like a beaten dog. He didn't even say goodbye to Sloane. He was a coward through and through—exactly what I had predicted.
Sarah looked at me and nodded once. A silent "thank you." Then she followed him out.
That left me, Sloane, Maya, and Chloe. The "Project" was over, but the cleanup was just beginning.
"Get out," I said to Maya and Chloe.
"Ethan, wait—" Maya started.
"Out," I repeated. "Before I decide that the 'joke' is funny enough to share with your bosses on Monday morning."
They didn't argue. They grabbed their bags and scurried out the door, leaving a trail of expensive perfume and shattered dignity behind them.
I turned back to Sloane. She was standing in the middle of the room, the silk dress now looking like a costume for a play that had been canceled halfway through.
"I cannot believe you did that," she hissed. "You ruined my life. You humiliated me in front of everyone I care about."
"No," I said. "You did that the moment you decided my respect was a punchline. I just provided the microphone."
"It was a joke, Ethan! A stupid, harmless joke!"
"A joke requires a victim to be in on the laugh, Sloane. I wasn't laughing. Sarah wasn't laughing. The only people laughing were you and your 'directors' over there. And honestly? I don't think you’re as funny as you think you are."
She took a step toward me, her eyes wet with angry tears. "What now? You’re going to kick me out too? Just like that? After three years?"
"Three years," I said, feeling a strange sense of lightness. "It took me three years to realize that I’ve been living with a person who views loyalty as an option and boundaries as a suggestion. I’m an investigator, Sloane. I don't ignore the data once it’s been verified."
"You’re cold," she sobbed. "You’re a cold, heartless machine."
"Maybe," I said. "But at least I’m not a joke."
She lunged for me then, her hand raised to strike, but I simply stepped back. I didn't need to fight her. She had already lost.
She thought she could stay, that she could cry and manipulate her way back into my life, but I had one more piece of evidence that she hadn't accounted for—something that would make her exit permanent...