Finding Derek wasn't hard. His profile was private, but his bio mentioned a local woodworking business in a suburb two hours away. I didn't call. I didn't message. I got in my car and drove.
If Ava was a professional, I needed to know the script she was following.
The shop was a small, dusty garage filled with the scent of cedar and sawdust. Derek was a man in his late thirties with tired eyes and hands that looked like they’d seen a lot of hard work. When I walked in and said Ava Jensen’s name, he didn't even look up from the lathe.
"You the new guy?" he asked. "Daniel, right?"
"How do you know my name?"
"She’s been posting about you for weeks. Or rather, a version of you. The version that drinks too much and yells at night. I figured it was only a matter of time before you ended up on the sidewalk."
He turned off the machine and wiped his hands on a rag. "Sit down, Daniel. You look like you’ve seen a ghost."
"She’s pregnant," I said, though it sounded like a question now.
Derek laughed, a dry, hollow sound. "She was 'pregnant' with me, too. For eight months. She even had the ultrasounds. I spent twenty thousand dollars on a nursery and medical bills I thought she was paying. Turns out, she was just pocketing the cash. When I finally demanded to go to an appointment with her, she 'miscarried' due to the stress I caused her. Then she called the cops, claimed I hit her, and walked away with half my savings while I was sitting in a holding cell."
I felt a wave of nausea. "How did she get the ultrasounds?"
"There are websites for that. You pay fifty bucks, give them a name and a date, and they send you a high-res image of a twelve-week-old fetus. It’s a whole industry for scammers."
"But the police... the house... the law protects her," I said, my voice cracking.
"Because the law is designed to protect actual victims," Derek said, his expression softening. "And people like Ava know how to weaponize that protection. They use the 'victim' label like a shield and a sword. She’s not just after your house, Daniel. She’s after your soul. She wants you to break. She wants you to do something stupid so she can justify everything she’s already done."
"I have proof she bought a fake belly," I said, pulling up my phone.
"It’s a start," Derek nodded. "But you need more. You need to prove she’s a serial fraudster. I have the police reports from Chicago. And I know a guy in Seattle she did this to before me. We’ve stayed in touch, just waiting for her to pop up again."
I spent the next three days in a war room at my motel. Derek and the "Seattle guy," a tech developer named Sam, sent me everything. Bank statements, fake medical records, restraining orders that had been overturned when her lies fell apart.
While I was building my case, the world outside was rotting. My mother called me, crying, asking if it was true that I’d "forced Ava to sleep on the floor while she was sick." My boss called me into a private meeting, telling me that "character matters" and that I needed to "sort out my personal baggage" or my promotion was off the table.
Ava was winning. Every day I didn't respond, her narrative grew stronger. She even did a "Live" video from my living room, showing the "empty nursery" she was supposedly building. Marcus was in the background, painting the walls a soft blue. My walls.
I wanted to scream. I wanted to drive over there and tear the door off its hinges. But I remembered Derek’s words: She wants you to do something stupid.
Instead, I went to the best family law attorney in the state. I didn't bring emotions; I brought a binder.
"I don't want an apology," I told the lawyer. "I want an eviction, a restraining order, and a defamation suit. And I want to do it all at once."
The lawyer, a sharp woman named Elena, flipped through the evidence. A slow smile spread across her face. "Mr. Vance, people like this usually move on before they get to a courtroom because their victims are too ashamed to fight back. You aren't ashamed, are you?"
"I’m past shame," I said. "I’m at the 'scorched earth' phase."
"Good," she said. "We’re filing an emergency motion to vacate based on fraudulent residency. And we’re subpoenaing her medical records. If she’s pregnant, a court-ordered doctor will confirm it. If she’s not..."
"She’ll run," I finished.
"Not if we serve her correctly," Elena said.
We set the trap. I didn't respond to a single text. I didn't "like" or "comment" on a single post. I stayed a ghost.
But then, I got a message from Marcus.
"Hey man, we found your 'stash' in the floorboards. Real classy. Ava’s calling the cops in the morning. You’re done."
I didn't have a stash in the floorboards. I realized they were planting evidence. If I didn't act in the next twelve hours, I wouldn't just be homeless—I’d be in prison.